[Verse 1]
You kept your keys beside the coffee tin
Like you might leave, but never knew when
I learned the shape of your silence by heart
You learned to sleep with your back turned in the dark
I brought two cups to the porch every night
You brought old fear and called it a life
I said, “Tell me where the hurt begins”
You said, “I don’t know how to let anybody in”
[Pre-Chorus]
I was a river running over its banks
You were a road with the signs taken away
[Chorus]
I loved you too much, you lost the way
Somewhere between “forever” and “don’t make me stay”
I held on tighter, you slipped through my hands
We made a hard thing out of a simple chance
Two hearts, one house, and a door between us
I loved you too much, you forgot how to need us
[Verse 2]
Your mother’s quilt still hangs by the stairs
Your Sunday shirt is folded in pairs
I found your note in the glovebox last spring
Three lines of goodbye and no reason for anything
You said I deserved somebody whole
I said you were more than the wounds you showed
But love can’t be a rope or a rescue boat
And I couldn’t teach your lost heart how to come home
[Pre-Chorus]
I was a fire burning down to the floor
You were afraid of what a warm room was for
[Chorus]
I loved you too much, you lost the way
Somewhere between “forever” and “don’t make me stay”
I held on tighter, you slipped through my hands
We made a hard thing out of a simple chance
Two hearts, one house, and a door between us
I loved you too much, you forgot how to need us
[Bridge]
Maybe in another town, another year
You’d believe the good things when they got near
Maybe I’d know the difference between faith and fear
Maybe we’d meet as men who could stay right here
[Final Chorus]
I loved you too much, you lost the way
I kept lighting candles you wouldn’t let me place
I held on tighter, you slipped through my hands
We made a hard thing out of a simple chance
Two hearts, one house, and a door between us
I loved you too much, you forgot how to need us
[Outro]
Your keys are gone from the coffee tin
The porch is quiet, but I still let the evening in
I loved you too much
You lost the way
And I’m learning how to love myself today